“Horror of Fang Rock” is a Doctor Who story about an evil alien that stalks the Doctor and the other inhabitants of a fog-enshrouded lighthouse. Somewhere on the English coast, around the year 1900, a scout ship from the Rutan empire crashes in the sea near Fang Rock. It raises a strange fog, slides out of the water, and moves to electrocute the strange mix of locals and Monte Carlo socialites who have taken refuge in the tower.

I didn’t remember this story being that good, but I was actually pleasantly surprised. “Horror of Fang Rock” was significantly better than I had remembered it from the first and only other time I watched it, about two decades ago now. It wasn’t an outstanding example of Doctor Who by any means, but it definitely had its moments. The acting was quite acceptable, and one of the themes of the episode was the way people from the British lower and upper classes behaved so differently when thrust into a difficult situation. One member of the lighthouse crew, old Reuben, was from local fisherfolk stock–a Luddite and superstitious, but practical. The rich lordling and his ilk were too self-obsessed to take adivce (or orders) from their social inferiors (which is, I grant, a stereotype). Two of the Earthlings are actually quite effective, but they get relatively little screen time; each of them is killed by the alien invader soon after first appearing.

However, what I really liked about the episode was the alien. The spaceship effects were really quite poor, just little blobs of light moving irrationally across still model shots. However, the Rutan, which resembled a giant glowing green sphere, with tentacles dragging behind it, was wonderful. Of course, it was just the sort of rubber alien that early Doctor Who was supposed to avoid, and I usually don’t like that kind of monster, but I guess I’m just a sucker for anything squid shaped. As it slimed its way up the spiral steps of the lighthouse (not the easiest thing for a ball of green protoplams to do), I almost found myself rooting for it, despite its intention to wipe out all life on Earth. When it spoke, however, I was a little disappointed. Not having made a Dalek story in several years, the crew apparently thought it was a good idea to use the same ring modulators that produced the eerie Dalek voices to make the Rutan’s voice sound unusual. I found the effect merely jarring, since the character of Dalek speech is too distinctive not to sound instantly familiar (although it did take me a couple lines of dialogue before I placed it).

I also liked the lighthouse keepers’ discussions of the merits and drawbacks of different kinds of lamps. They were very natural sounding, and Reuben’s resistance to the use of electical arc lamps seemed very rational for a circa 1900 lighthouse worker. The whole argument sounded to me (as somebody who is very interested in the history of technology) extremely authentic and interetsting.
The acting by the regular cast was mixed. Tom Baker’s Doctor seemed much less all-knowing than usual. More and more information about the Rutan piles up, but he remains unable to identify the monster’s species until he confronts it in person (even though Rutans are major players in the universe, apparently). This is quite a contrast to the Time Lord who could identify his location (in “The Power or Kroll,” another squid episode) with little more than a glance around at the swamp. Leela, on the other hand, behaved significantly more reasonably than she normally does. Her recommendations that everyone find weapons and defensible positions (a common feature in many of her stories) were atypically apt. She admonishes one nervous young man not to believe superstitions; although she once did, the Doctor has taught her about science, and, “It is better to believe in science.” Finally, and this is probably why I liked Leela’s performance (I usually don’t care for her character)–her hair was not its usual, ridiculously straight and tidy self. It got messed up and frizzed in the mist, like a real warrior’s should.
Speaking of Louise Jameson’s appearance, I am now reminded of the low point of the story, which came at the very end. The alien mother ship is destroyed in a blast of brilliant light, which Leela, against instructions, looks back at. She is temporarily blinded, and asks the Doctor to slay her, not wanting to live with such an infirmity. This comes off as ridiculous, but it’s followed by her eyes changing color, which the Doctor explains away with some especially unconvincing sciency mumbo-jumbo. Obviously, the real explanation was that Jameson didn’t want to wear lenses to darken her eyes any more. It would have been better just to drop the lenses and act like nothing had happened (like they later did when Peter Davison abruptly stopped dyeing his hair before his last season as the Doctor). I certainly wouldn’t have noticed, nor would I have rolled my eyes.